People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Food is always good and reasonably priced. Service is always fast and friendly. Restaurant is always clean. ”
“ The decor is beautiful, very clean. Service was pleasant and cheerful. The food was delicious. Carnitas and a choose 3 plate with quesadilla, chimichanga and tamale, kids burgers. ”
“ Visited 11-19-24. Had the pollo loco plate. It looks very simple, but it has great taste. The rice had good flavor and texture, but the beans tasted a little sour. The plate don’t come with tortillas, but I ate it with tortilla chips. The dipping sauce is really good. ”
“ We dined on a Monday evening. Never been to this part of the county to dine. I ordered Papi’s fajitas which were steak, chicken and shrimp served with typical fajita vegetables and plate of beans, rice, guacamole, sour cream salad. It had great flavor, service was fast and friendly. I don’t like that a review in here said that they talk about you in Spanish. Obviously you were a terrible customer. ”
“ Great food, kind staff, quick service, and it was nice and clean inside. I definitely reccomend giving this place a shot! ”
“ Our server Cody did a fantastic job of making sure that we were extremely well taken care of. With this experience we will be visiting again. The food was delicious and served very quickly. My wife ordered the carne asada tacos and the first question asked was cilantro and onion or cheese so we knew this was an authentic restaurant. I got the shrimp chimichangas and they were amazing. This is a great restaurant and I suggest that if you haven't already visited them you make the trip. ”
“ Good food and service. Great margaritas! ”
“ Great restaurant with friendly service and amazing food. In town for work and this will be my go to spot! ”
Menu
Nachos Supreme
US$8.09Nachos with Chicken
US$5.99Enchilada
US$2.39Tamale
US$2.59Papi's Fajitas
US$14.99
About
Margaritas Mexican Restaurant - Middlebury
Welcome to Margaritas Mexican Restaurant - Middlebury!
Nestled in the heart of Middlebury, Indiana, at 500 Spring Valley Dr, Margaritas Mexican Restaurant is a culinary gem that transports you straight to the vibrant streets of Mexico. With a commitment to offering authentic Mexican flavors, this restaurant has established itself as a beloved spot for both locals and visitors alike.
From the moment you step inside, the lively decor and warm ambiance create an inviting atmosphere. Patrons are consistently greeted with friendly service, as noted by customer reviews praising the quick and cheerful staff. The attention to cleanliness is also commendable, making it a comfortable dining experience.
- Appetizers: Start your meal with the mouthwatering Nachos Supreme, available with chicken or beef, beans, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream, and guacamole for just US$8.09. Alternatively, you can go for the classic Nachos with Chicken for only US$5.99.
- Main Courses: The highlight here is undoubtedly Papi's Fajitas. Choose between chicken, beef, shrimp, or a combination that includes chorizo, served with all the classic sides like rice, beans, guacamole salad, and pico de gallo—all for a reasonable price, ranging from US$14.99 to US$15.99.
Customer feedback echoes the excellence of the dishes served. Diane raves about the reasonable pricing and consistently good food, while Micah describes the delightful blend of flavors in the carnitas and the mixed plate that showcased the varied menu options. Christie's experience with the Papi’s fajitas emphasizes both the vibrant taste and the efficient service. Each dish reflects a balance of flavor and freshness that is hard to find.
We also appreciate the thoughtful details in the presentation of the meals, as seen in Manuel's review of the pollo loco plate. While simple in appearance, the great taste and quality ingredients shine through. The complimentary dipping sauce is a delightful touch, perfect for pairing with tortilla chips.
In summary, Margaritas Mexican Restaurant - Middlebury is a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic Mexican cuisine in a welcoming environment. Whether you are in the mood for a hearty main course or a quick bite, this restaurant offers something for everyone. Don't just take our word for it—come experience a slice of Mexico right here in Middlebury!
For inquiries and reservations, feel free to call them at +1 574-825-5454.
Book a table